Citrine, known for its radiant hues ranging from pale yellow to deep orange, is one of the most sought-after semi-precious gemstones. Natural citrine is a form of quartz, just like its purple counterpart, amethyst. However, genuine citrine is relatively rare in nature, given that its formation requires higher temperatures. As a result, the practice of heat-treating amethyst to mimic the appearance of citrine has become quite common in the gemstone market.
From Amethyst to Citrine: A Journey Through Heat
Amethyst, another highly desired semi-precious gemstone, is a macrocrystalline quartz that develops its dreamy purple coloration when it cools below 420°C (788°F). When the crystals form between 420°C and 440°C, the result is prasiolite. However, when temperatures exceed 440°C (824°F), citrine is formed. This transformation is all down to iron inclusions within the quartz, which respond to these different temperature ranges
Given the abundance of amethyst and the scarcity of naturally occurring citrine, scientists have found a way to manually induce this transformation. They heat amethyst in a kiln that reaches the same temperatures necessary for nature to convert amethyst into citrine. This process results in a heat-treated amethyst that bears a striking resemblance to natural citrine
Spotting the Difference: Heat-Treated vs. Natural Citrine
Although heat-treated amethyst and naturally occurring citrine are almost identical, several subtle indicators can help distinguish one from the other.
The color of the stone can be a significant giveaway. Natural citrine tends to exhibit pale yellow to gold or straw yellow shades, with color-zoning being quite common. On the other hand, heat-treated amethyst often leans more towards orange-yellow hues. It's essential to be cautious of stones with burnt-looking tips or a single uniform color, especially if it's a large piece, as these characteristics may indicate a heat-treated specimen.
Natural citrine is more likely to be found as smaller points or other formations, whereas heat-treated amethyst often appears as crystal formations from the inside of large geodes. Citrine rarely forms in geodes, so if a piece looks like it was cut from a geode's exterior, chances are it's not natural citrine.
Some natural forms of citrine exhibit dichroism, an optical effect where the stone shines with different colors depending on the orientation of the crystals. While dichroism can prove a stone is natural, the absence of it doesn't necessarily mean the stone is heat-treated.
What About Their Chemical Composition?
The chemical makeup of heat-treated amethysts citrine and natural citrine is fundamentally the same. Both are varieties of quartz, a form of silica (SiO₂), with iron inclusions present within the crystal structure. These inclusions are responsible for the distinctive colors of both forms of citrine. The primary difference between the two lies not in their chemical composition, but in the conditions under which they are formed. Natural citrine forms when amethyst or smoky quartz is heated to high temperatures by the earth's natural geothermal processes. Heat-treated citrine, on the other hand, is created when amethyst is subjected to similar high temperatures in a controlled, human-made environment, such as a kiln. Despite the differing origins, the end result is a gemstone with the same chemical composition and similar physical properties in both cases.
Are Their Metaphysical Properties Similar?
The metaphysical properties of natural citrine and heat-treated amethyst citrine are a subject of ongoing debate among crystal enthusiasts and healers. Some believe that the process of heat-treating amethyst to create citrine changes the metaphysical properties of the crystal, while others assert that the energy remains similar. Natural citrine is often associated with the sun's energy, promoting happiness, creativity, and personal will. It's thought to carry a powerful transformative energy that encourages personal growth and manifestation. Heat-treated citrine, while still considered a stone of abundance, is sometimes reported to have a more grounded energy due to its amethyst origins. It's worth noting that the perception and experience of a crystal's metaphysical properties can be highly individual and may depend on the user's intent, sensitivity, and openness to the crystal's energy.
Heat-Treated Amethyst Citrine Pricing
Heat-treated amethyst, also referred to as citrine, is very common and affordable. You can find small raw heat-treated citrine crystals priced between $2-$10 a piece.
Natural Citrine Pricing
On the other hand, natural citrine is relatively rare, as it requires high temperatures to form, and most of it is found in Brazil. This rarity is reflected in its price. Natural citrine is more expensive than its heat-treated counterpart, with large pieces potentially costing hundreds of dollars. In particular, high grade citrine, which boasts a deep, attractive color, can cost thousands of dollars.
Factors Influencing the Price of Citrine
The price of both heat-treated and natural citrine can be influenced by several factors. The intensity and uniformity of the color, the size and shape of the stone, and the presence of any flaws or inclusions can all impact the cost. For instance, heat-treated citrine with a uniform, vibrant orange-yellow color may be priced higher than a piece with a less desirable color or a piece that shows color zoning.
Buying Citrine: What to Look Out For
When buying citrine, always ask about the origins of the stone. As a buyer, you should be aware that heat-treated amethyst is very common and makes up around 95% of all citrine on the market. Therefore, unless stated otherwise, it's safe to assume that most citrine you come across has been heat-treated. If the price seems too good to be true for what is being sold as natural citrine, it might very well be.
Despite the difference in price, both natural and heat-treated citrine can be excellent choices for collectors. Citrine has a good hardness level (7 on the Mohs scale) and lacks gemstone cleavage, which makes it resistant to chipping and suitable for everyday wear. Whether natural or heat-treated, a citrine piece can hold its value for years to come.
The transformation of amethyst to citrine through heat treatment is a fascinating process that reflects humanity's ingenuity in enhancing the beauty of natural stones. Though it's essential to note the difference between heat-treated citrine and its natural counterpart, both have a place in the world of gemology and crystal healing. Whether you prefer the more abundant heat-treated citrine or seek the rarity of natural citrine, both stones carry the vibrant energy of sunlight and creativity, making them a cherished addition to any collection.
*The statements made on this website have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration. Our products are not intended to diagnose, cure, or prevent any disease. If a condition persists, please contact your physician or health care provider. The information provided by this website or this company is not a substitute for a face-to-face consultation with a health care provider, and should not be construed as individual medical advice.